Critique Time!

Posted on

Maniacal Genius
Contributor Since: Dec 30, 2002

hey all,

I wanted to see if a few of you might take a listen to the couple of tunes I posted in the members music area. They're in the Rock section and called Telepathy and Crawlspace. I'm still working with them a bit, but I'd love to hear what you guys think.

Thanks in advance.

[ Back to Top ]


Contributor
Since: Dec 30, 2002


Jan 14, 2003 04:29 pm

Hey Erik,

Seeing as you took the time to download one of my tracks to listen to, I returned the favour for your track "telepathy"

The first thing that struck me was the quality of the acoustic guitar - very lush, and very effective when it first comes in with that meandering piano line underneath it. Continuing on the "I like, I like" theme, the hats are beautiful, very crisp and detailed.

Okay, now for the flipside, here's what I would address...

1. The Kick doesn't stand out at all. Did you mic it? If so then try shoving on about 9dB of gain at 4KhZ with quite a tight Q (or just boost the HF if your EQing options are limited)

2. The Snare is well recorded, but IMHO the reverb doesn't sit too well on it - Are you using the same reverb you used on the vocals? Try a dark plate reverb with some of the high end rolled off on the reverb return and a short (9ms ish) decay - this can work really well to warm that snare up a bit.

3. The Bass - I presume there is a bass guitar in there (or there is at least a bass synth, no?) It is distinguishable, but it's not really eating up that low frequency is it? Your whole mix seems very shy on the bass side. I whacked on a bit of LF boost (+6dB at 80Hz) on my console and it instantly brought out the bottom end thus warming up the whole track and giving it more presence.

If you don't mind I will have a quick pop at mastering it and post the results on the web.

Other than those small production points, I thought the result was great - there is little hiss and everything sits well in the mix - especially the vocal. As for the song writing, it's not my cup of tea, but I found myself humming the bass line afterwards - can't be bad :)

Laters
jonny.

Maniacal Genius
Contributor
Since: Dec 30, 2002


Jan 14, 2003 04:46 pm

Thanks a ton for your input. The drum track was created from a couple of loops so I don't have the luxury of EQing the kick separately from the rest of the kit. On top of that, I realized after I had already used that loop, the kick is pretty loose sounding in the first place. Nonetheless, I'm sure your suggestions will help. I'm even considering adding another track and sequencing another kick to try to get some "punch" into it. Beyond that, I'll apply your suggestions and am sure will come up with a better result. It would be fantastic if you could play with the mastering of it a bit. I would love to hear what you can do with it!

Thanks again!

Contributor
Since: Dec 30, 2002


Jan 14, 2003 05:16 pm

Hey Erik,

Well, I've done a quick 10 minute master job on your track to bring out the bass and bring about a bit more warmth and clarity to the midrange.

You can grab it at flipcycle.stemfiction.com/cyclik/tel_mast.mp3

Laters,
jonny.

Maniacal Genius
Contributor
Since: Dec 30, 2002


Jan 14, 2003 05:47 pm

I'll have to take a listen when I get home from work where I can turn it up a bit more than I can here. I really appreciate you taking the time to do this. Your feedback is valued greatly.

Related Forum Topics:



If you would like to participate in the forum discussions, feel free to register for your free membership.