Message Forums
Home > Community > Computers & Software Forum > Upgraded to Win XP: FAT32 or NTFS, which system is better for studio aps? - Computers & Software Forum
Computers & Software Message Forum
| Svengali Stick Player Member Since: Mar 07, 2005 ![]() |
Mar 07, 2005 05:37 pm I've mostly old stuff> HP Pavillion PII 930 Mhz 256 SDRAM 40Gig HD Most of the programs I run are pre XP: Cool Edit 2.0, older Pro Tools, Sonor XL 2.1, Older Cubase. I'm getting Reason 2.5. Only that and my Line 6 Guitarport/XT Live applications are post XP. Win manual suggests NTFS but I'd like to hear from someone who's actually done it w/ older apps. |
|||||
| dB Masters HRC Czar Administrator Since: Apr 03, 2002 ![]() |
Mar 07, 2005 05:45 pm NTFS is always better. |
|||||
| pjk Prince CZAR-ming Member Since: Apr 08, 2004 ![]() |
Mar 08, 2005 01:58 pm I read somewhere you should use NTFS with large block size on your audio partion / hard drive. This will let your HD write in bigger chunks at a time. YMMV. |
|||||
| vdalehubbard Lost for words with all to say. Contributor Since: Sep 12, 2003 ![]() |
Mar 08, 2005 02:00 pm NTFS, newer and better and will work with your older applications. |
|||||
| dB Masters HRC Czar Administrator Since: Apr 03, 2002 ![]() |
Mar 08, 2005 02:21 pm NTFS is more stable, more secure and generally better performing. There are some VERY old apps and games and such that may not like it, but, if not, it's worth upgrading your apps. FAT file systems should be avoided if possible. But, be aware, upgrading your OS and changing to NTFS will wipe out your HD and you'll have to reinstall everything. |
|||||
| BeerHunter Car Czar Member Since: Feb 07, 2005 ![]() |
Mar 08, 2005 02:31 pm Hello all, Hey! Finally a thread that I can confidently contribute to! NTFS vs. FAT32 Here are some key comparisons Maximum Volume Size on both is 2TB Maximum File Size on FAT32 is 4GB (limited only by volume size on NTFS) NTFS has builtin security Overall performance on NTFS is low on small volumes and high on large volumes. FAT32 is the opposite with high performance on small volumes and low on large volumes Anyways, IMO, use NTFS. PS - great site. Been lurking about for awhile now and I have already utilized lots of the information obtained from this site. |
|||||
| dB Masters HRC Czar Administrator Since: Apr 03, 2002 ![]() |
Mar 08, 2005 02:37 pm OK, now I could get along with a user named BeerHunter. Welcome to the conversation...even tho it appears you joined a while ago...and just been keepin' quiet. |
|||||
|
||||||
| BeerHunter Car Czar Member Since: Feb 07, 2005 ![]() |
Mar 08, 2005 03:40 pm Thanks for the welcome dB. Ya, just been keeping quiet. I'm really new to home recording and I have so much to learn so I've been digging through the forums to try and get myself up to speed. |
|||||
| dB Masters HRC Czar Administrator Since: Apr 03, 2002 ![]() |
Mar 08, 2005 03:42 pm thats a good place to start...ya have any questions, we are all ears :) |
|||||
| j8x Member Since: Feb 23, 2005 ![]() |
Mar 08, 2005 06:07 pm My .02.... I'm kinda locked in to using fat32 partitions because I record onto a Mackie MDR recorder, and take the drive dock out and edit on my PC. My boot drive and storage partitions are ntfs though. I did run the boot drive fat32 but if you do that when you format it a few things happen that can be of benefit and/or a hindrence (sp?) The larger the drive size the larger the "clusters" will be. The best analogy I can think of without giving in to ADD....ooh look at the bird!...anyways, when you partition and format a fat32 drive it will create "spaces" for data from 4096 bytes to hold a chunk of data and if you get larger drives it will format them with larger and larger spaces. As much as 32k in size. I believe you'll also run into ,depending on your BIOS, a maximum size drive you can format fat32. The data you save on the drive will be less efficient and take up more space. One of the "benefits" in my case, is that my 32 gig fat32 drive can read data as much as 50 megs a second, compared to my ntfs drive reading at 30 megs/sec. I can play 24 tracks of 24 bit wavs without even a hiccup. YMMV. But I can only have 32 gig drives max for audio. I have a third 120g drive just for storage. If you record audio onto a computer get a large 2nd drive and format it ntfs and it will be better all around. IMO Your 40g boot drive should be ntfs too. |
|||||
Rules and Etiquette
Note to spammers: - all links embedded within our forum are marked with a "nofollow" directive to crawlers from search engines, so any links you leave behind to your sites for Ugg boots, body part enlargement supplements, get rich quick sites or other such things will not gain you any improvements in search engine rankings.
By registering for membership to HRC you agree to act in a manner that is respectful of the fellow members and law abiding. This prohibits, but is not limited to the following:
Failure to abide by these rules can lead to removal of your content and possible banning of your profile. Common sense prevails, just respect your fellow forum members and we will all have fun and learn a lot.
Registering for membership lists you under the typical member status. The following membership levels currently exist:
Privacy Policy
The information given in registration is the sole property of HRC and will never be sold, traded or otherwise given to anyone. We have no interest in promoting spamming or any form of annoying online marketing. Your information is kept private except for what you allow to be seen in your personal profile.
The Home Recording Connection web site does use cookies on the visitors machine to authenticate users logged in status and track which user they are, as well as the use of cookies by HRC's third party advertising systems and to support visitor analytics systems. These cookies are not dangerous and not intended to exploit any theft of information in any way, they are simply a tiny text file storing a string of characters that are used strictly for tracking user visit and geolocation information to show the users more relevant advertisements and give us a more accurate view of who uses this web site so that information can help us make it more useful for those using it.
The cookies used by the Google ad serving system uses the DART cookie which enables it to serve ads the visitor based on their visit to this site and other sites on the Internet. HRC visitors may opt out of the use of the DART cookie by visiting the Google ad and content network privacy policy.
For more information about HTTP Cookies, read Wikipedia's post on the subject.
Home > Community > Computers & Software Forum > Upgraded to Win XP: FAT32 or NTFS, which system is better for studio aps? - Computers & Software Forum
If you would like to participate in the forum discussions, feel free to register for your free membership.
[ Home ] [ Search HRC ] [ Help Support HRC ] [ RSS/Feedburner ] [ Contact Us ] [ Advertise on HRC ] [ Privacy Policy ]
Home Recording Connection is hosted on HostPC servers, the best web hosting available.
Reproduction of original content within this site without permission is prohibited. All content copyright ©2010 Home Recording Connection.
Home Recording Connection is owned and operated by dB Masters Multimedia. All rights reserved.